Popular Posts

  • Writing a Master's Thesis
    It's that time of year when my MSc students are starting to seriously worry about choosing a dissertation topic. With that in mind here ...
  • Life is stranger than art
    It's funny how occasionally you come across little snippets of information that momentarily knock your otherwise stable image of the wo...
  • Brian Barry
    Brian Barry, who died earlier this week, was a political theorist I admired. I can't claim to be an aficianado of the genre but I enjoye...
  • On metaphors - cultural and social capital again
    Recently, as you no doubt know,  I've been beating up on the use of the term "capital" in phrases like "cultural capital...
  • Shaking the Tree
    Friday was International Women's Day. Of course I didn't notice until it was pointed out to me by a colleague. So, belatedly, here...
  • The break up of Britain
    Whether they knew it or not, the interest that drew them there was purely psychological - the expectation of some essential disclosure as t...
  • Chakrabortty on Economics
    Aditya Chakrabortty  has another of his ill-informed rants about academic economics in today's Guardian . I don't need to defend e...
  • The Great British Class Fiasco
    It's been a bad week for my blood pressure. I'm trying manfully to ignore the hooplah arising from MT shuffling off her mortal coil...
  • We all know social mobility has declined right? Well no, it probably hasn't.
    If you study social mobility you are pretty much forced to study it through the rear view mirror, looking back, as it were, over your should...
  • ABCD
    If I knew what this case (reported in today's Guardian ) was about I wouldn't be able to tell you and until very recently I wouldn...

Caveat Emptor

The opinions expressed on this page are mine alone. Any similarities to the views of my employer are completely coincidental.

Tuesday, 17 January 2012

Why journals do not contain a record of continuous scientific progress

The inimitable Ben Goldacre has ferreted out a useful early example of a discussion of publication bias. Fifty years on and my impression is that things are not greatly improved in some disciplines. Add publication bias to the belief on the part of some editors of sociology journals that their organs are part of the entertainment business and you have the perfect recipe for the reproduction of blah blah.
Posted by Colin at 02:29

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)