tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2210395876281973177.post6092924525427149372..comments2023-09-05T02:06:11.217-07:00Comments on Oxford Sociology: GBCS comment outColinhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/03430614811751115687noreply@blogger.comBlogger2125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2210395876281973177.post-23417674926049107402014-03-27T02:28:17.695-07:002014-03-27T02:28:17.695-07:00... why, Mike, why? Perhaps we'll find out whe...... why, Mike, why? Perhaps we'll find out when the reply to the critics finally sees the light of day, or maybe it will just be a lot of blather. Given the number of people involved it's likely to be a horse designed by a committee.<br />Colinhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03430614811751115687noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2210395876281973177.post-44564772057604891132014-03-26T15:33:17.988-07:002014-03-26T15:33:17.988-07:00Ta for letting my Tony Benn chat pass. I'd say...Ta for letting my Tony Benn chat pass. I'd say more about the details of the GBCS debate except I've no had academic uni access since forever. At a superficial level, I would say the lense of Mike Savage's own work over time strikes me as being an interesting slant on sociology as a whole. <br /><br />By this I mean, contra Harriet Bradley, Mike is someone who has clearly wrestled with establishing explicitly relational approaches to class to an extent that became increasingly silly (in some of his his edited collections - go, go Karl Renner!).<br /><br />He's similarly wrestled with notions of ethnicity, place, gender and class (as per an edited work a certain Colin Mills contributed to). This in turn addresses the chat off yer man Rollock and Dorling.<br /><br />So really I reckon the question becomes one of why did Mike focus on constructing the kind of tosh categories a marketing firm churns out every other Sunday given he genuinely knows better - why Mike, why? <br /><br />That and why do sociology big dogs just fall into line when it comes to trotting out what are presented as critiques that actually come across as no more than prejudice burps?<br /><br />I mean seriously, Mike Savage gave sociology a national stage at a time of galloping social inequality and social science cutbacks - the tenured academic response? Hmmm, that's as maybe, but if I ignore his earlier work I get to trot out my prejudices that make clear how groovy I am.Primula Monkeyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09289100326536298640noreply@blogger.com